MORRISTOWN (WATE) – Hamblen County Sheriff’s Office said two suspects were “surprised and shocked,” when deputies showed up to arrest them in a 13-year-old cold case.
Johnny R. Kirk, 53, and Carmen M. Kirk, 43, of Morristown were both charged with first degree murder, felony murder and robbery and arrested without incident. The charges are related to the murder of Mickey Michelle Moore on March 3, 2003.


Moore died of blunt force trauma in her driveway after returning home from Howard’s Pharmacy in Morristown, according to the sheriff’s office. They said after a friend couldn’t reach her for more than 24 hours, she found her dead in front of her home.
“Every day you ask and wonder how, wonder why, wonder when they’re going to come to justice,” said Moore’s niece Kim Sipe.
The family saying the news of the arrest is bittersweet. “Today is a big sigh of relief. She’s gone and there’s nothing going to bring her back. But to know that somebody for 13 years has walked around scot-free and capable of murder, it was just a huge load off my family’s back,” said Sipe.
The sheriff’s office said new information that Johnny and Carmen Kirk were supposed “friends” of Moore and knew her routine, helped them make arrests in the case.
“We brought them in before for questioning but they were always on our radar. Everything always came back to these two,” said Carrie McCann, Public Information Officer for the Hamblen County Sheriff’s Office.
Deputies said they believe the two suspects waited in her driveway for Moore to get home from the drug store.

“Knowing her, she probably felt sorry for them at some point in time or took them in. That’s how she did,” said Sipe.
The same detectives have been working on the case since day one. “He made a promise to this family, we will find the people who did this. yes it’s been 13 years and we hate that it took this long but he made a promise that night,” said McCann.
Tuesday, it’s no longer unsolved and loved ones no longer have to wait for more answers but all the while they held onto hope.
“It may be 20 years from now but the truth always comes out at the end. It really does,” said Sipe.
Johnny Kirk and Carmen Kirk are each held on a $250,000 bond. Both suspects were scheduled for arraignment on Nov. 6, but the date was moved to Jan. 29.
